Saturday, October 23, 2021
Saturday, October 23, 2021
HomeFact checkNewsAfghan Journalist Refutes The Claim Of His Death By Taliban, Says He...

Afghan Journalist Refutes The Claim Of His Death By Taliban, Says He Was Attacked

A tweet by TOLO news -Afghanistan’s foremost news channel- announcing the death of their staff member,  journalist Ziar Khan Yaad was liked and retweeted hundreds of times within a short span of time on the morning of 26th August. 

Originally posted in Farsi/Persian, a translation of the post by Google reads  “TOLO news reporter killed by Taliban in Kabul”.

Journalist killed
Screenshot of the TOLOnews tweet

Twitter users including Indian news agency ANI, retweeted the death of Yaad quoting TOLOnews. ANI’s tweet was further retweeted over 800 times within the first few hours.

TOLOnews reporter
Screenshot of the ANI tweet
Zair Khan Yaad
Taliban attacked journalists

Fact check/Verification

The claim made by TOLOnews was refuted on Twitter by a post made from the official account of the same journalist in the photograph, Ziar Khan Yaad. 

The post said that while he was indeed beaten up by the Taliban in Kabul, the news of his death was false.

Zair Khan Yaad refutes his death
Screenshot of Yaad’s tweet

Yaad’s tweet came minutes after TOLOnews announced his death. He further wrote on Twitter, “I still don’t know why they behaved like that and suddenly attacked me. The issue has been shared with Taliban leaders; however, the perpetrators have not yet been arrested, which is a serious threat to freedom of expression.”

attacked by Taliban
Screenshot of Yaad’s tweet

Following the clarification of Yaad, TOLOnews posted further details of the incident saying, ”TOLOnews reporter Ziar Yaad and his cameraman were beaten by Taliban in #Kabul city while they were working on a report on Wednesday.” 

Kabul city, Afghanistan
Screenshot of TOLOnews’s tweet

Native Farsi speakers also pointed out that this confusion about the reporter’s death had arisen due to incorrect translation done by Google from Persian to English. Among them was BBC’s South Asia bureau chief Nicola Careem who wrote, “Warning – the google translation of this tweet is incorrect. The correct translation is “Taliban BEATEN Tolo news reporter in Kabul”,” on Twitter.

incorrect google translation
Screenshot of Nicola Careem’s tweet

Conclusion

The news of the death of Ziar Khan Yaad is false. The tweets posted on the death of the journalist were based on an erroneous translation done automatically on the post by Google.

Result: False


Our Sources

The tweet from journalist Ziar Khan Yaad: https://twitter.com/ziaryaad/status/1430769985702535170?s=20

BBC’s Nicola Careem’s tweet: https://twitter.com/NicolaCareem/status/1430768821690769414?s=20

TOLOnews’s tweet adding further details on the status of the journalist:

https://twitter.com/TOLOnews/status/1430779962903121922?s=20


If you would like us to fact-check a claim, give feedback or lodge a complaint, WhatsApp us at 9999499044 or email us at checkthis@newschecker.in. You can also visit the Contact Us page and fill the form.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular