Connect with us

Fact check

Old Claim Of Revathi Selected As IAS Officer from Karnataka Is Misleading

Revathi was selected as a Sub-Inspector (SI) of Police by the AP government in 2017.

Published

on

Old Claim Of Revathi Selected As IAS Officer from Karnataka Is Misleading

Claim 

A tweet posted on 27 June, 2020 claims that a woman named Revathi received third rank in the civil service examination and got selected for IAS from Karnataka.

This claim was posted by Amitava Chakravorty, State Jt. General Secretary of the Bharatiya Janata Party in Bengal. Accompanied by two photographs, it also claims that she was being congratulated by her parents who are daily wage workers on this occasion. 

We found this claim to be widely circulating on social media platforms including Facebook and Twitter since 2017. Examples of this can be seen below. 

IAS Topper 3rd Rank Miss.Revathi, from Karnataka got selected for I.A.S. She is being congratulated by her parents who…

Người đăng: Indian Administrative service – IAS vào Thứ Bảy, 8 tháng 7, 2017

Fact Check

Since the claim in context was first found to be released in 2017, we searched for Revathi in the list of selected IAS officers in that year. Based on the 2016 Civil Services Examination result, which was released in 2017, Revathi’s name does not feature in the third spot or in the entire selected candidate list

On performing a reverse image search of photographs in the claim, we came across an article published by journalismpower.com on 26 March 2017. It includes the same two photographs used in the claim plus an additional photograph of Revathi. The article states that the woman in the photograph is indeed Revathi and she’s from Avanigadda District in Andhra Pradesh (AP). It further details that Revathi was selected as a Sub-Inspector (SI) of Police by the AP government in 2017. 

Taking cue from the article linked above, we reached out to the Andhra Pradesh Police department to enquire about Revathi and her current post in the police. They connected us to Revathi who informed us that her full name is in fact Mathi Venkata Revathi. She also clarified that it is her in the photograph and it was taken in Modumudi village, Avanigadda District in Andhra Pradesh. Currently, she is the Sub-Inspector at Disha police station in Rajahmundry city, East Godavari district, AP. Finally, she was not selected for IAS from Karnataka. 

Conclusion

The claim in context which has been circulating on social media platforms since 2017 is misleading and partly false. The woman in the photograph is Revathi, but she did not get selected for IAS from Karnataka. She was selected to be a sub-inspector in Andhra Pradesh in 2017 and currently serves as the SI at Disha police station in Rajahmundry City, AP. 

Tools Used

  • Reverse image search
  • Google advanced search 
  • Twitter advanced search

Result: Misleading, Partly False 

If you would like us to fact check a claim, give feedback or lodge a complaint, WhatsApp us at 9999499044. You can also visit the Contact Us page and fill the form.

Authors

Continue Reading

Fact check

The Claim On British Airways Permanently Shutting Down Is False

British Airways confirmed with us via email that it’s not shutting down its airline services nor did they create the video in context.

Published

on

British Airways Is not Permanently Shutting Down

Claim 

A message claiming the airline service, British Airways, is permanently shutting down due to heavy business loss incurred during the COVID-19 pandemic has been widely circulating on Whatsapp. 

Whatsapp message claim on British Airways permanently shutting down
Whatsapp message claim on British Airways permanently shutting down
Video claiming the closure of British Airways

This Whatsapp message is being shared with the above video claiming to be created by the airlines. 

Similar social media posts claiming BA’s shut down can be viewed here and here

Fact Check

As a first point of verification, we searched through the British Airways (BA) website for any information that suggests their permanent closure. In their Coronavirus travel and service updates section we came across updates on new protective measures introduced by the airline and more. Last updated on 26 June at 15:20 (at the time of writing this fact check), this section does not include any information on permanent closure of their services.

BA published a press release on 2 July, 2020 on their website’s media centre stating that the Airways reopens its routes throughout July. 

British Airways 2 July, 2020 press release on reopening routes
British Airways 2 July, 2020 press release on reopening routes

Next, we looked up their social media accounts on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram for any posts that suggest the closing of BA. Again, we couldn’t find any information related to this on these platforms. 

In fact on 20 June 2020, BA posted a video on their official Youtube page saying they look forward to welcoming people back on board. The description reads:

“In the past few months, we’ve all been missing the people and places we love. When the world opens up once more, we are looking forward to welcoming you back on board…”

British Airways video on welcoming its customers back on board

Verifying the claim video

Through a reverse image search of certain video frames as well as a keyword search on Youtube, we came across a channel named Unite the Union Yout which seems to have originally posted the video in context on 14 June 2020. Its description reads: 

“British Airways has applied to dismiss all of its staff from 15 June 2020. Before we leave you, the staff of British Airways would like to say thank you and goodbye. #WeAreBA” 

On 9 May, this account posted a video titled “A message to British Airways from its staff” after the company announced its plan to lay off thousands of staff members in order to restructure. We found this account to be impersonating another Youtube channel called Unite the Union which is the trade union representing BA’s stewards and stewardesses. The former has copied the actual trade union’s logo as seen below. 

Top image is of the Youtube account impersonating the official trade union channel shown below.
Top image is of the Youtube account impersonating the official trade union channel shown below.

Let’s note that the airline has recently been in news for firing 350 of its staff and putting another 300 staff members in a pool for rehire when needed, reports The Sun. A couple of weeks back a Transport Select Committee Report accused the airline of taking advantage of the pandemic after they announced a massive restructuring which would include 12,000 layoffs and changes to the terms and conditions of remaining staff. 

As a final confirmation, we directly reached out to British Airways, who confirmed with us via email that BA is not shutting down its services and the video in context was not created by them.  

You can read our other fact checks related to COVID-19 pandemic here.

Conclusion 

After receiving official confirmation from British Airways, we can safely say that the airline is not shutting down its services. 

Tools Used 

  • Reverse image search
  • Twitter advanced search
  • Google advanced search

Result: False 

If you would like us to fact check a claim, give feedback or lodge a complaint, WhatsApp us at 9999499044. You can also visit the Contact Us page and fill the form.

Authors

Continue Reading

Fact check

Prashant Bhushan Does Not Support Islamic Terrorists Nor Did He File A PIL Against Tik Tok Ban

The claims in context are with regard to Prashant Bhushan, an advocate in the SCI and come after his response to Tik Tok India’s contribution of Rs. 30 crore to the PM Cares fund.

Published

on

Prashant Bhushan Does Not Support Islamic Terrorists Nor Did He File A PIL Against Tik Tok Ban

Claim

A Facebook post claims that Prashant Bhushan is standing for Tik Tok and has a history of supporting Islamic terrorists and anti-national people. This claim was posted 1 July, 2020 by a Facebook account called राष्ट्रवाद सर्वोपरि.  On checking its page transparency we found that the account was created on 17, May 2020.

Prashant Bhushan is standing for TikTok. प्रशांत भूषण का इतिहास रहा है हमेशा इस्लामिक आतंकवादी और एंटी नेशनल लोगों का साथ देते हैं l 😡

Người đăng: राष्ट्रवाद सर्वोपरि vào Thứ Tư, 1 tháng 7, 2020

Accompanied with this claim is a screenshot of another post from a Twitter account called The Express of India which claims that Bhushan filed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) in the Supreme Court against the government order to ban 59 Chinese apps. 

https://twitter.com/ExpressOfIndia/status/1278187485294505984?s=20

The screenshot from The Express of India is widely circulating on social media platforms since yesterday. Below is an example of another viral image.

Image of viral social media post claiming Prashant Bhushan files PIL against government order of ban on 59 Chinese apps.
Image of viral social media post

Fact Check

The claims in context are with regard to Prashant Bhushan, an advocate in the Supreme Court of India. These claims come after his response to a Twitter post by Tik Tok India which states that it’s making a contribution of Rs. 30 crore to the PM Cares fund. Bhushan’s 30 June tweet says, “Tik Tok’s humble contribution of 30 Crores to humble Chaiwala’s fund! So ungrateful!” 

The first claim in the Facebook post alleges that Bhushan stands for Tik Tok and has a history of supporting Islamic terrorists and anti-national people. We haven’t found any credible evidence or news story which suggests this. Therefore, this claim has no basis to support it. 

The accompanying screenshot is from a parody Twitter account (@ExpressOfIndia) created on 20 April, 2020 with 571 followers at the time of writing this fact check. The description in its profile reads:

“Independent Satire News Outlet. Parody Editorial. All Tweets Are Fake. In Memory Of @TiimesHow.”

This Twitter account impersonates the actual news organisation The Indian Express by trying to copy its logo, font and doing a wordplay with its name. See image comparing the two accounts below:

Image of parody account on the left. Image of authentic news organisation on the right.
Image of parody account on the left. Image of authentic news organisation on the right.

The parody account in its bio pays its “respect” to the now suspended fake account @TiimesHow

Screenshot of suspended Twitter account @TiimesHow
Screenshot of suspended Twitter account @TiimesHow

Implication of “1 particular community” in the tweet is to the Muslim community in reference to recent stories about them using Tik Tok in this pandemic.  

As a final confirmation, we reached out to Mr. Bhushan himself, who clarified on call that he did not file any PIL in the Supreme Court against the government order of banning the 59 Chinese apps and that the claims are false. 

Our other fact checks related to Tik Tok can be read here.

Conclusion 

The claims in context with regard to Prashant Bhushan are false. 

Tools Used 

  • Twitter advanced search
  • Facebook
  • Google advanced search 

Result: False 


If you would like us to fact check a claim, give feedback or lodge a complaint, WhatsApp us at 9999499044. You can also visit the Contact Us page and fill the form.

Authors

Continue Reading

Coronavirus

Aamir Khan’s Ghulam Co-Star Javed Hyder is not selling vegetables to survive, Misleading Claim goes Viral

The media reports claiming that Javed Hyder is selling vegetables to survive during ongoing Corona virus pandemic is false.

Published

on

Aamir Khan’s Ghulam Co Star Javed Hyder is not selling vegetables to survive, Misleading Claim goes Viral- Newschecker.in

Several media outlets shared a TikTok video of Aamir Khan’s Ghulam co-star Javed Hyder selling vegetables and claimed that he is doing so to survive during ongoing Coronavirus pandemic. Here are some screenshots of the media outlets who reported the same.





Big Boss fame, Dolly Bindra also shared Javed Hyder’s video and tweeted, ‘He is an actor, and today he is selling vegetables…Javed Hyder’. In the viral TikTok video, Javed Hyder is selling vegetables while dancing. He is lip-syncing the famous song ‘Duniya Mein Rehna Hai Toh Kaam Kar Pyaare.’ You can see the video here.

We found that the same claim is viral on Twitter, Facebook and WhatsApp.

The quint also published an article claiming the same. However; they updated their report later on with a disclaimer.

Fact Check

With the help of relevant keywords search on Google, we found several articles clearing the air on the viral claim. In his conversation with Mirror Online, Javed Hyder clarified that he is not a vegetable seller, and the video was just for TikTok.

No, I am not a vegetable vendor. I am an actor by profession even now. The entire selling vegetable video was just an act and I shot that TikTok video only to motivate my followers

Javed Hyder To Mirror Online.

Later, Hindustan times and News 18 India also published an article stating the same.

Conclusion

It is evident from our fact check that media reports claiming that Javed Hyder is selling vegetables to survive during the ongoing coronavirus pandemic are false. Javed Hyder clarified that he is not selling vegetables for a living, whereas the viral video is just a musical one that he made to keep himself busy during the lockdown.

Sources

  • Google Search
  • Twitter Search

Result: False


(If you would like us to fact check a claim, give feedback or lodge a complaint, WhatsApp us at 9999499044. You can also visit the Contact Us page and fill the form)

Authors

Continue Reading

Copyright © 2020 NC Media Pvt. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.