Friday, August 6, 2021
Friday, August 6, 2021
HomeFact checkDid Nepal Or China Cause Flooding In Bihar & UP?

Did Nepal Or China Cause Flooding In Bihar & UP?

Do China and Nepal have anything to do with floods in Bihar and parts of Uttar Pradesh this week?

Prominent Indian TV channels like ABP News, Aaj Tak and News 24 alleged that the floods which claimed 16 lives in Nepal and endangered many lives in India happened due to Nepal releasing water into rivers Gandak (Narayani) and Kosi which caused further Inundation.

ABP news claimed that Nepal released 4.5 lakh cusecs of water from the Gandak barrage

Aaj Tak website carried the following article making similar claims.

China and Nepal
Article Published By AajTak On 17th June

In addition, TV channel News 24 called it a ‘water attack’ by Nepal claiming it was done ‘with the backing of China’. In a report dated June 16th, 2021 from the Koshi barrage near the Nepal-India border, their correspondent claimed that China and Nepal are developing six hydropower projects in Kathmandu’s northeast district, Sindhupalchok and have diverted 11 rivers.

News 24’s video clips have gone viral amongst Nepali TikTok users, most of whom have criticized the media for its “inaccurate and baseless reporting”. Which prompted our investigation into these claims.

Many other media outlets also reported similar claims

Fact check/Verification

Did Nepal Deliberately Release Water Into Gandak And Kosi Rivers?

Newschecker’s investigation shows that the flooding in Nepal and north Indian states of Bihar and UP occurred due to sudden heavy monsoon rains in the Himalayan districts of western and central Nepal on and after June 15. 

According to Nepal’s Weather Forecasting Division, Department of Hydrology and Meteorology, a low-pressure system remained over central Nepal during June-13-16, causing record rainfall of up to 214 millimetres on June 15 in the western Syangja district of Nepal.

Screenshot From Department of Hydrology and Meteorology, Nepal (Website)
Screenshot From Department of Hydrology and Meteorology, Nepal (Website)

We also found one of the screenshots of News 24 which is being shared on TikTok is 2 years old.

Screenshot of a viral TikTok Video

The video can be seen below. This show was broadcasted on 13 July 2020.

Gandak And Kosi Barrages

Google Earth: Gandak Barrage
Google Earth: Kosi Barrage

Information Officer at Nepal’s Ministry of Energy, Water Resources and Irrigation Babu Raj Adhikari told Newschecker: “The Koshi and Gandak barrages are looked after, repaired and operated by the Indian officials as per the bilateral agreements. Nepali officials have no role in opening or closing the gates.”

The water resource department in Bihar confirmed to Newschecker that India operates the barrages. 

Speaking to Newschecker, Bihar Water Resource Department’s engineer-in-chief (Flood Control And Water Drainage), Mr Rajesh Kumar, said that the department is responsible for “maintaining and operating the barrages”.

Hindi news website, Hindustan also reported an official from the Maharajganj Irrigation Department, Rajiv Kapil, saying that they lifted 36 floodgates of the barrage.

News Report Published By Hindustan On 15 June

Did Nepal Divert 11 Rivers For China-Backed Six Hydropower Projects?

The special report broadcasted by News 24 on 16th June claimed that China is developing six hydropower projects in Kathmandu’s northeast district, Sindhupalchok, along with Nepal. It also alleged that Nepal had diverted 11 rivers which in turn is affecting India. 

Nepal’s Ministry of Energy, Water Resources and Irrigation has denied this claim, with its Information officer Babu Raj Adhikari calling them ‘completely false and inaccurate.” 

Sinohydro, a Chinese construction company, is involved in one project in Sindhupalchok, which borders Tibet, a drinking water diversion project in the Melamchi river basin, but that, too, got severely affected by this week’s landslides and floods.

Screenshot of the Melamchi Drinking Water Project Agreement

In the past, Sinohydro won contracts to develop parts of two hydropower projects in west and east Nepal, including Upper Marshyangdi, and Upper Tamakoshi, but not in Sindhupalchok as claimed by News 24. 

Conclusion

The claims made by the Indian channel, News 24, suggesting China and Nepal have a hand in current floods in north India are false.

Result: False


Our Sources

Water Resource Department, Bihar

http://mfd.gov.np/content/?id=3138

https://www.nepalitimes.com/banner/disasters-in-nepal-come-in-waves/

https://www.moewri.gov.np/storage/listies/May2020/aggrement-on-nepal-and-india-gandak-river-1959.pdf

https://www.internationalwaterlaw.org/documents/regionaldocs/gandak-project.html

https://www.internationalwaterlaw.org/documents/regionaldocs/kosi-river1.html

https://www.facebook.com/Sinohydro.B6/

http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2019-09/30/c_138437365.htm

http://www.melamchiwater.gov.np/about-us/melamchi-ws-project/project-description/

(Surendra is Newschecker’s Nepal fact-checking consulting editor)


If you would like us to fact check a claim, give feedback or lodge a complaint, WhatsApp us at 9999499044 or email us at checkthis@newschecker.in. You can also visit the Contact Us page and fill the form.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular